Like Urban Research on Facebook

Sunday, November 10, 2024

Why Public Transit is Always Late (And How Cities Can Fix It)

This video deals with a short history of public transportation and also some of the reasons of its delays.
Public transit isn't a modern invention. In fact, cities have been working on ways to move people around for thousands of years. Take ancient Rome, for example. They had a system of carriages and wagons regulated to control traffic and congestion.

Watch this video here and learn more. 

 

The Roman Roots of Public Transit


Public transit isn't a modern invention. In fact, cities have been working on ways to move people around for thousands of years. Take ancient Rome, for example. They had a system of carriages and wagons regulated to control traffic and congestion.

Rome even had something like “bus lanes” — certain streets, known as banned streets, were off-limits to carts during daylight to reduce congestion. Sound familiar? It's like the early version of “No Delivery Trucks Before 10 AM”! But even back then, they couldn’t escape delays. Julius Caesar, the emperor himself, probably wasn’t immune to late arrivals due to traffic jams!

 

19th Century: Railroads and Streetcars


Fast-forward to the 19th century, and we enter the golden age of horse-drawn streetcars and railroads. The Industrial Revolution caused cities to expand rapidly, and with that came increased demand for transportation.

One key example is London, which was among the first to develop an extensive railway network. The London Underground — opened in 1863 — was groundbreaking but far from perfect. Within a few years, delays were frequent, caused by issues like:

  • Overcrowding (sound familiar?).
  • Mechanical failures (steam-powered engines would break down in tunnels).
  • Congested tracks.

The situation was no better in Paris. When the Paris Métro opened in 1900, it faced similar struggles with overcrowding, breakdowns, and poor coordination — problems that still plague many transit systems today!

 

Why Public Transit is Late Today?

Now, why is public transit still late in 2024? Let’s break it down:

1. Traffic Congestion

Buses, the workhorses of many city transit systems, have to share the roads with everyone else. In New York City, for example, buses move at an average speed of just 7.4 miles per hour — yes, slower than you might walk in some areas like Manhattan!

According to a 2017 study, 30% of bus delays in major U.S. cities are due to traffic congestion, and the problem is only getting worse with increasing urbanization.

2. System Overcrowding

When transit systems don’t expand fast enough, overcrowding causes delays. Take Tokyo’s Yamanote Line, where station staff (known as oshiya) literally push people into trains during rush hour. More people = more time to board = more delays.

In Tokyo, 20% of train delays are attributed to overcrowding alone. During peak hours, the trains operate at 200% capacity, causing cascading delays throughout the network.

3. Infrastructure Failures

In the U.S., many transit systems operate on aging infrastructure. The Washington D.C. Metro, for instance, suffers frequent delays due to outdated tracks, signal failures, and deferred maintenance. According to a 2019 report, the Metro faced over 16,000 hours of delays due to infrastructure issues that year alone!

4. Coordination Problems

Running a transit system is a logistical nightmare. If one bus or train is late, it can have a domino effect across the entire system. In London, the so-called “knock-on effect” happens when one delayed train causes delays for all subsequent trains. One study showed that 30% of delays on the London Underground were due to such chain reactions.

 

Case Study: Mumbai’s Train Network

Now let’s look at Mumbai, where around 7.5 million people use the suburban rail system every day.

Overcrowding:

Mumbai’s suburban trains operate at 300% capacity during rush hours. No, that’s not a typo — it’s literally packed beyond human limits. This overcrowding means longer boarding times and frequent delays.

Lack of Modernization:

Despite its importance, Mumbai’s train system hasn’t kept pace with the city’s rapid growth. According to a 2018 study, 40% of train delays in Mumbai could be attributed to insufficient investment in modernizing the infrastructure.


Solutions: How Can Cities Fix Public Transit?

Now that we know why public transit is always late, how can cities solve this problem?

1. Dedicated Bus Lanes

Cities like Bogotá, Colombia have found success by giving buses their own lanes. The TransMilenio bus rapid transit system uses dedicated lanes, speeding up buses by 35% and reducing delays.

2. Automation & AI

Automation can help make transit systems more efficient. In Copenhagen, the Metro is fully automated, reducing human error and improving punctuality. Similarly, Tokyo is testing AI to predict delays and reroute trains in real-time. Early tests showed that AI could reduce delays by 20% during peak hours.

3. Infrastructure Investment

Cities like Seoul, South Korea, have invested heavily in modern infrastructure. In the last decade, Seoul spent over $50 billion modernizing its transit system, and the results speak for themselves. Seoul’s transit network is now among the most reliable in the world, with 95% of trains arriving on time.

4. Congestion Pricing

London’s Congestion Charge Zone has significantly reduced traffic in central London, cutting down bus delays by 12%. By charging cars to enter certain parts of the city, it frees up road space for buses.

5. Urban Design & Planning

Curitiba, Brazil, took a holistic approach to city planning. The city’s transit system prioritizes public transport by using prepaid boarding stations to speed up bus boarding times. This simple design change reduced boarding time by 30%, making the system more efficient overall.

 

The Future of Public Transit

Cities are experimenting with bold new ideas to make public transit not only more efficient but also more enjoyable.

Example: Singapore’s Smart Nation

Singapore is a world leader in smart transit technology. Using big data and AI, the city has developed a bus system that adjusts routes in real-time based on traffic patterns and demand. This has reduced bus delays by an impressive 25% and made the system much more responsive to passenger needs.

 

Conclusion

Will public transit ever be 100% on time? Probably not, but cities are finding creative ways to make it a lot better. Next time your bus or train is late, take a deep breath, and remember — at least you’re not stuck in a Roman chariot traffic jam! 

By including more detailed data and case studies, this version of the script gives viewers a clearer understanding of the various factors affecting public transit delays and the efforts made by cities across the world to improve their systems.

 


More about urban transportation:

No comments:

Post a Comment